How do you have sugar one day (on one of your four days a year, for example) and not have it turn into two days, and then three, and so on. How do you have it.. then not have it? I went with out sugar one time for about a year and a half, then at a surprise birthday party for me I succumbed to peer pressure and had a piece of birthday cake (“ONE PIECE WON’T HURT YOU!”) and that was the beginning of the end.
Thanks,
Jill
I choose to do it. Halloween and my birthday are days where I want to eat sweets. Doing so makes it easier for me to participate with the activities of those days. I failed 1,000 times before getting to the point where I could make it a year without sugar. Having the 4-day window where I choose to eat whatever I want came as a result of much experimentation. I had gone weeks, months, and finally a year before settling in on those 4 days.
Once you’ve been off sugar long enough and then go back, you notice that it’s not all it’s cracked up to be. Knowing that helps to make eating sweets less attractive. After a year and a half sugar-free, you’re well aware of that.
In the end it’s really a matter of choice. Social pressures are a huge factor but people rarely hold us down and push cake into our mouths. That said, there is no doubt that someone would have been very hurt had you not eaten the sweets they made for your surprise birthday party. They’d have gotten over it though.
When you stop being sweet you get to know your boundaries. The only way that happens is to have them crossed and then feel upset about it afterwards. Then you think, “I’m not letting that happen again.”
What’s most frustrating about your story is that, had you not cracked under the pressure and given in, you would have flipped the script. Everyone would have been forced to give up the old, sweet you and accept the new, unsweet you. At your next birthday they’d know you mean business and people would be in awe of your ability to resist sugar. But you caved. And that’s perfectly okay. It was your choice. It has been your choice all along.
You chose to eat healthily for a year and a half and you chose to eat something sweet on your birthday. You’ve been in control all along and you still are, right now. Choose wisely!
Respectfully, this article bothers me a bit. Succumbing to sugar one day and not the next may be a “choice”, but it is also a strongly mediated physiological urge too. For many, this “choice” is about as easy as declining a drink for an alcoholic. Would you write an exerpt for alcoholics suggesting that it’s simply a choice for them to drink 4 times per year and then resist the rest? No one who understands addiction would go there. I believe that for many people…probably most people who would bother to visit your site, that this option isn’t viable. I have recently removed sugar from my diet, and I can tell you with certainty that the last 400 times this method did’t work for me. In fact, it’s one of my favorite things to tell myself before spiralling back into sweets.
I appreciate your site and hope you will reconsider this advice.
DavidVanadia
Sep 04, 2011
Hi Anna, I completely agree that there is a physiological urge to eat sugar. There are also peer and other pressures.
While I and many others like to compare the two, sugar addiction is not alcoholism. Related, yes. The same, no. Compared to alcohol: You can eat your body weight in sugar and drive a motor vehicle. Kids eat sugar. Sugar is added to your food at restaurants and you don’t even know it. Sugar is something we HAVE TO deal with.
It is absolutly my choice to eat sugar 4 days a year. That works for me. It took 1,000 failures to be able to succeed there. I don’t advise that for everyone.
I recommend you figure out what works for you and remember that what you eat is always your choice. Physiological urge, peer pressure, hunger, whatever—it’s up to you.
• Tips, Tricks, Info & News
• My Personal Journal
• Reviews & Recipes
• No Sugar Challenge
• Sweet Stories
• Frequently Asked Questions
View the Archive
• What It Means to SBS
• 20 Ways to Stop...
• 10 Sugar-free Snack Ideas
• Common Trigger Foods
• Get Off Sugar Now
• Keeping Sweets at Home
• Why Avoid Sugar?
• Top 10 Excuses
• Audio Presentation
• Avoid Sugar at Work
• 10 Reasons to Stop
• Saying No to Friends
INGREDIENTS: DETERMINATION, DESIRE (YOU HAVE TO WANT IT), FUN, WILLPOWER, SELF-WORTH, SUPPORT, CONFIDENCE, EXERCISE.

I realized I had a sugar problem back in 2003 after a weekend-long binge on raw chocolate chip cookie dough and chocolate covered pretzels. As a result, I began trying to quit sugar but kept failing. Finally, I figured out a way to stay off sweet junk food for good.
Don’t quit sugar. Stop Being Sweet instead! Questions? Please ask!
Anna
Sep 04, 2011